Realspace Soho™ X-280 Mesh/Vinyl High-Back Chair, 47"H x 26 1/4"W x 26 1/4"D, Black/Gray

Pros: Appearance/Design, comfortable, features
Cons: Size & Weight

Basically, it's a comfortable chair; however, if you are a small female like me (5-1), your feet may not be able to reach the floor. When I lie back, I feel comfortable and relaxed on the chair. I like it, but again, it's not perfect for short people.

Pros: Appearance/Design, features, functional, Well Made/ Sturdy
Cons: uncomfortable

The only good point I would give this chair is its appearance. Very modern and expensive looking. But now the bad points. The vinyl is extremely noisy when it rubs against the plastic arm rests. After just a few days the seat becomes unbearably uncomfortable. The material is average, but the cushioning is almost non-existent. I wouldn't recommend this chair at all.

Pros: Appearance/Design, features, functional, Quality of Material, Size & Weight, Well Made/ Sturdy
Cons: uncomfortable seams

This chair has a lot of good things going for it.
The only drawback I 'feel' is the seam, in the seat section and the armrest section. It feels uncomfortable.

Pros: Appearance/Design, comfortable, functional, Quality of Material, Well Made/ Sturdy

I was in need of a new office chair. As a lawyer, I sit at my desk for 8+ hours several days a week. This chair is comfortable and has padding in all the right places. As an added bonus, it has a sleek, modern look.

I needed a high quality chair for several hours at my desk. I have been looking for a long time and sitting in a lot of chairs in the stores. This chair is wonderful. Easy to build. I put a 20 minute pizza in the oven and assembled the chair before the pizza was ready. Also included were extra bolts. I love this chair.

I purchased two of these chairs for my law firm. They were extremely easy to assemble and I have been very satisfied with the comfort and quality. I sit at my desk 8+ hours per day and I have not had any issues with the chair thus far. I also purchased a 3rd one today for my home use, using a 25% off furniture coupon.

Pros: comfy seat, seems quite durable, pretty good bargain overall
Cons: not quite as adjustable as i would hope, bit rigid out of the box

Like the other guy, I'm fairly big, 6'3, 220. To find a chair, reasonably priced and fits/feels good is rather hard to come by. I paid less than half of list for this thing and, overall, I'm fairly pleased with it.
Out of the box, the chair is a little stiff but that is to be expected. I spend about 4-5 per day sitting in front of a computer so this chair seems a comfy alternative to any stock office chair I have in my office.
The seat is really comfy and cushiony so that's a plus. I wish the back would adjust but for this kind of chair, I wouldn't expect this as an option. Pretty easy to assemble and, again, really comfy. For the price (assuming you paid less than retail for this thing) is quite a bargain.
Only real downside is that since I'm tall, the "headrest" is more like a neck rest. Other than that, it's a nice chair for home or office.